If the game is rigged, you don’t have democracy

Think of it this way — democracy is hard to do. To achieve true democracy you need to have an educated electorate. If citizens don’t know what their public officials are up to, they can’t make intelligent choices. In fact, they can be led around like donkeys. When that happens, public officials can put anything out there, take a bow, and say, “We did it and you should thank us.” Take the case of Governor Andrew Cuomo. After New York got the reputation of being dysfunctional, Cuomo came in and set things right, at least he said he did.

Among his other accomplishments, he got the state Legislature to establish a single ethics commission governing all public servants. Good stuff — really. Among other things agreed to was that the Legislature would appoint many of the members and that the Senate Republicans, in or out of the majority, would get the lion’s share of the picks for commission, now and in the future. That would be like agreeing that if the Democrats won the next election, that the Republicans would be allowed to pick the Supreme Court justices after each vacancy. No matter, Cuomo got the bragging rights for having done the impossible. The more he says it, the more people believe it. The more people believe it, the higher his popularity soars.

There is also the question of redistricting and efforts to put an end to the insidious self-serving gerrymandering that allows legislative majorities to draw districts where they have the best chance of winning. Cuomo ran for office on that one. “I will veto that bill,” he intoned time and again. In fact, he said it so many times that I believed it. I admired him for it and said so, in my columns and on the radio. The problem was that the redesigned Cuomo, now a sort of Blue Dog Democrat, appears to like the Republican conservative-moderates in the state Senate in the majority. If he stuck to his guns and vetoed the bill and everyone got a fair chance in blue state, Democratic New York, the Democrats would win big and have the kind of majority that they enjoy in the state Assembly. Now I admit that the Democrats don’t deserve any rave reviews for their past performance. Nevertheless, we are talking democracy here. If the game is rigged, and believe me it is, you don’t have democracy.

Into all of this comes the old New York City Mayor, Edward I. Koch, who has said all along that he supports Cuomo for his determination to veto the corrupt, morally repugnant, anti-democratic redistricting bill. Cuomo and Koch have had their problems in the past but they made up, I am sure, partly based on Cuomo’s assurance that he would veto the terrible gerrymander. But, politics being what they are, Cuomo began to waver. He began to hint that in politics you have to give something to get something. The question then is whether what you give is more than what you get. In this case, the agreement seemed to be that in ten years (!) there would be a very bad constitutional amendment that would allow the legislative minorities to continue to do then what they are doing now. But, if Cuomo gets an agreement, he will once again say that he won.

So the technique is now established. Cuomo’s very high popularity numbers have begun to dip. Two groups are very angry. The New York teachers believe that they have been very badly treated by the governor, as do the labor unions representing the state’s public servants. His popularity drop has only been a few points and by itself, a five or six point drop in the polls is nothing. But if the numbers continue to drop, the Cuomo folks will take notice. If Andrew Cuomo is anything, it is tough.

If he has to make concessions, he will. But Team Cuomo doesn’t take nicely to those who oppose them. Like the Cuomo staffer said to the gutsy Governor Dannel Malloy from Connecticut, “We operate on two speeds here: Get along, and kill.”

Originally published in the Legislative Gazette, March 12, 2012

Explore posts in the same categories: Uncategorized

One Comment on “If the game is rigged, you don’t have democracy”

  1. Will Pflaum Says:

    You have noted some problems with the ethics bill and the Joint Commission. But you don’t hammer the ethics kabuki theater hard enough in my opinion. For example, the commission does not have jurisdiction over local, town, county, village and municipal ethics. This is a glaring omission. The NYSBA Task Force on Government Ethics report (January 28, 2011) pointed out there is no one on the case in terms of the local guys. It’s anything goes in the counties. The Joint Commission will be rigged and claim no jurisdiction over almost everything. We’d be better off with no pretense of oversight.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: